214 Lake Street – Reno, Nevada
Going back to the 1870s, the east side of Lake Street just north of Second was dotted with small wood frame dwellings. By the 1890s, sturdier and more substantial homes had been constructed but the neighborhood wasn’t the best. Some of the single-family homes became rooming houses with spotty reputations. Around 1904, residents included laborers, harness makers, and the occasional attorney.
Harry Armstrong moved his restaurant to 200 Lake Street in May of 1906.

That building had been converted for a mix of residential and commercial purposes with a rooming house at the back. Canton Laundry also operated on the property.

Herbalist Dr. L Sing began advertising at 206 Lake in 1910. That house was also used as a laundry for several years.

The first three lots actually had an international variety of laundries: Chinese, French, Japanese, and later…Italian.

By 1918, the north half of the block was all brick but development in Lots 1-3 was a bit slower. Directly across the alley to the east was a series of cribs labeled as “Female Boarding.” That was code for houses of prostitution.

Joseph Pincolini bought the property at what was then 204 Lake Street in March of 1921.

A building permit was granted in July of 1921 for a three-story hotel to be operated by the Pincolini brothers and their families. Joe and Dante Pincolini are shown here during excavation of the basement.

The Pincolinis hosted a grand opening event at the Mizpah Hotel on January 1, 1922.

The brick hotel, shown here around 1922, had commercial spaces on the main floor and a dining room for guests toward the back of the building.

Dante, Adelvaldo, and Lazzaro Pincolini are shown here in the Mizpah lobby.

Like many of their fellow Renoites, the Pincolini family wasn’t fond of the National Prohibition Act. Various family members had been arrested for minor violations but the Mizpah was raided in August of 1922.

After a lot of back and forth, the hotel was ordered closed effective May 1, 1923. The rooms were scheduled to open after three months but the dining room was to be closed for a full ten months. This was said to be the first closure of a hotel under the Volstead Act.

The family fought the ruling which went to the United States Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit. A transcript of the proceedings can be read here. Judge Farrington allowed the hotel to reopen at the beginning of July but said the order closing the bar stood. The Pincolinis had to pay for a hotel watchman who would enforce Prohibition laws.
Mizpah Cafe opened in the building in February of 1925.

Business was good and a building permit was issued that May for a $20,000 hotel expansion.

The new addition included a mix of 28 rooms and apartments.

The Mizpah established itself as a residential hotel early on and converted a few rooms into four additional apartments in December of 1926.

Daniel Andreotti and Angelo Matteuccci sold the former Mizpah Cafe to Joe Martini by December of 1926 and it became known as the Trovatore. That establishment ran afoul of the dry laws as well.

Joe Pincolini had a close call in February of 1930 when Harry Lee fired three rounds in his direction after being told to leave the hotel.

Lee was fined $20 for the drunken lapse in judgement.

The Pincolini brothers purchased the neighboring lots to the south of the Mizpah in February of 1931 with plans to expand the hotel all the way to Second, filling the space eastward to the alley. This would create a U-shaped hotel with a narrow courtyard in the middle.

This photo shows the corner prior to the addition. You can see the brick storefront added to the front of the old rooming house with a ladder propped against the wall.

During excavation work in May of 1931, a cache of gold coins reportedly totaling $20,000 was uncovered at the work site. That figure was surely a typo but still an exciting find!
The Pincolini family opened Reno Public Market in the new space at 201 E Second in June of 1932.

Another exciting development was the end of Prohibition. The Mizpah Club at 210 Lake and the new Manhattan Bar at 200 Lake applied for liquor licenses in April of 1933. Other early occupants of the Mizpah addition were De Luxe Cleaners, Heinie’s Cafe, American News Co. of Nevada, and a liquor store operated by the Pincolini brothers.
William Ramos leased the former Manhattan Bar in the corner spot in the Spring of 1937 and opened the Lake Street Pharmacy that May. Ramos also owned the Lake Street Cigar Store next to the drug store. William Pettis bought the pharmacy in May of 1940.

During the 1940s, commercial spaces were leased to McWade’s Plumbing and Heating Shop, Nevada Cleaners, Lake Street Tobacco Shop, Nevada Paint and Floor Service, and William Lee and Sons Repair Shop.

On August 15, 1948, an explosion on the west side of Lake Street blew out several windows in the Mizpah.

Despite being warned of the danger, several hundred spectators had gathered in front of the hotel to watch a fire when the explosion occurred. Glass rained down upon them as they tried to take cover. Sparks Fire Chief Frank B Hobson was among those killed.
By 1953, the Lake Street Pharmacy had become part of Reno Drug.

Its new neighbors in the 1950s included Nevada Relief Association, Nevada Novelty Co., and Nevada Coin Machine Service.

The Mizpah Bar had become a bit unruly by the mid-1950s. In February of 1957, bartender John A Spears was arrested for assault with a deadly weapon after shooting patron John C Pehrson in the head. Pehrson had allegedly been asked to leave and instead chucked a glass at the bartender’s head. Due to repeated emergency calls, the bar was ordered closed in April of 1958.
Multiple relief agencies operated in the Mizpah building with a dedicated thrift store, multiple rummage sales, and the St. Vincent Dining Room.

Reno Drug Co. was liquidated through a bankruptcy sale in November of 1966.

That corner space was leased to Leon Mack where he opened Plaza Loan and Jewelry in 1967. Mack’s neighbor, Violet Odom, operated the Santa Claus Market at 209 E Second for several years. Unfortunately, for Violet, people thought it was funny to rob the store every Christmas.

Most of the robbers carried knives, some guns, and some just alluded to having guns. By 1969, the robberies and burglaries began occurring in all seasons. The Santa Claus Market finally cleared out around the end of 1976. St. Vincent Dining Room relocated to West Third Street in 1977.

Liquor stores seemed to do well in the Mizpah building. Bi-Rite Market was open by December of 1980.

Brian Linton opened Mama Lena’s Fine Sandwiches in the space at 205 E Second in the Spring of 1981. Dragon Town Restaurant opened at 201 E Second in March of 1983.

The Mizpah Hotel, still owned by members of the Pincolini family, was added to the National Register of Historic Places in 1984. The building retained most of its original features, though some were covered for practical purposes. At the time, the hotel had 110 rooms, 68 of which included bathrooms. 22 of those also had kitchenettes.
Richard Cummings moved his Hair Designs Studio to 203 E Second in 1989. In July of 1990, the Dragon Town Restaurant changed hands and became Pho 777, which opened to rave reviews. Plaza Loan and Jewelry began their moving sale in May of 1992.

That store was later leased to an establishment called Reno Hotel, which hosted acts such as an all-male dance revue.

By the end of 1997, the corner space was being remodeled for Two Giraffes Bar and Grill, which opened in March of 1998.

The bar was called Longnecks by June of 1999. It became Shifters Bar and Grill around July of 2003 followed by Sac’s Bar and Grill around the Spring of 2005, and finally Blind Onion Pizza & Pub by February of 2006. That year, the family was hard at work renovating and redecorating the Mizpah, which was also for sale. In October of 2006, mattresses were being replaced and several were leaned against walls in the hallways.
On Halloween, a resident named Valerie Moore had a verbal dispute with a neighbor named Maxie Birch in Apartment 1. Moore, on parole for the second-degree murder of a woman who allegedly refused her advances, moved at least one of the mattresses against Birch’s door and set it on fire.
Birch said he smelled smoke, opened the door, and made his way down the closest fire escape. Twelve of his neighbors were not so lucky.

Twelve-Fatality Hotel Arson Reno, Nevada
USFA-TR-164/May 2008, p 16.
The roof over the original north wing was completely destroyed.

In addition to the twelve fatalities, another 31 were injured.

Parts of the north wall were demolished in order to safely search for additional victims and then that section was completely taken down. It took several days to recover the victims with the twelfth being found around November 7, 2006. A floor actually collapsed during demolition and tipped over an excavator.
Initially, the family believed the south 1931 addition could be saved.

However, the heating plant had been located in the original part of the building. That loss, coupled with the smoke and water damage, made restoration far too expensive.

In January of 2007, Moore avoided the death penalty by pleading guilty to arson and the first-degree murders of Alford Yates, Kevin Sutherin, William Serrao, Jeremy Wren, Diana Pochini, Gregory Wiltse, Ernest Duarte, Paul Smith, Christopher Covert, Nadine Nicodemus, Philip Bridges, and one unidentified person.
The remaining section of the Mizpah was used for firefighter training prior to its demolition in April of 2007. Its circa-1931 neon sign was saved and had been in storage until around 2012 when it was purchased from the family for restoration. The last mention I found was in 2018 when it was listed for sale as part of the closure of Sippee’s children’s clothing store.
Ground was broken for construction of the Ballpark Apartments in April of 2002.
This is how the former site of the Mizpah Hotel looks today:
A plaque is located at the southwest corner of the building commemorating the Mizpah Hotel and the lives lost to someone who probably shouldn’t have been paroled in the first place.
If you like what you see, be sure to subscribe (way at the bottom of the post on mobile devices) to receive an email each time a new post is published and share on social media. You can also support my work by donating below. This content is 100% funded by history fanatics such as yourself. Thanks for reading!
Donation
Your support keeps the content flowing! Make a one-time donation. Your contribution is appreciated!
$5.00


























































































































































































































































