Asa Titus Soule of Rochester, New York was a character. Whether or not he had any business influencing the affairs of Southwest Kansas is another story for another day. In 1887, Soule made a deal with some local Presbyterians to build a college north of Dodge City. The original 40-acre campus was located north of the bypass between 14th and Melencamp Avenues.
I think many locals recall the story of Soule being approached by a few landowners who wanted the college near their properties. He definitely saw it as an opportunity to further cement his legacy. What I don’t know is how the plan evolved into such an extravagant campus. The committee members must have been gobsmacked when they realized the extent of their responsibilities. Full disclosure: My great-great-grandfather, Chalk Beeson, was on the committee. Ida was *very* Presbyterian.
The Larned Presbytery accepted the proposal in April of 1887 for a building costing not less than $30,000.

This is the second mention of an endowment fund, which was essential. Unfortunately, that’s not what happened. Also, the college was not initially named after Soule.

The original plan was for Soule to donate $50,000 in cash. The committee decided to spend $20,000 on a college building, $10,000 on a dormitory, and then the remaining $20,000 would start the endowment. Construction was to begin right away so the buildings could be ready by October of 1887. Again, that’s not what happened. None of it went as planned.
The Soule College Erection Association, a not-for-profit corporation, was formed on June 29, 1887. Directors were W. C. Shinn, Samuel Mullendore, L. K Soper, M. W. Sutton, and J. W. Gilbert. They began accepting bids in July. Architects were Weston and Manning.

Reverend Benjamin F Powelson, who was selected to oversee the college, rented a home in Dodge that August and made plans to relocate his family. The school was to operate in the rooms over Marsh’s store on Front Street during construction. But this wasn’t really the beginning of the college. Rather, it was more of a preparatory school.

Powelson opened the preparatory school’s first term on September 7, 1887.

The bids were finally opened mid-September and the contract for $34,000 was awarded to William W Lawson and L. K. McIntyre. An additional $5,000 had been added to the available funds due to subscriptions from the public. Excavation work was reportedly completed by the first week of October and they had already begun laying the foundation.
Meanwhile, the second term opened with more than 60 students and the cornerstone was supposed to be laid in December. Kansas weather had other ideas.
College of Western Kansas was formed on March 13, 1888.

The cornerstone, cut by D. J. Rogers, was finally laid on April 5, 1888.

Marshal of the Day D. M. Frost, Assistant Marshal F. A. Heineke, and the Dodge City Cowboy Band led the procession from McCarty’s rink on Second Avenue to the college site. At that time, the ladies’ dormitory was mostly completed, only lacking finishing work, and the foundation of the main building had been completed.
This description supplied by the architects explains a bit about what happened to that endowment fund. What got lost in the shuffle was the $1,400 bond put up by the architects to protect against cost overruns versus their initial estimates.
So a $35,000 plan that included two dormitory buildings became a $50,000 plan with only one. And that left zero dollars for the endowment. I could just end the post right here. But I won’t. A streetcar line to the college was supposed to be operational by September of 1888. But it obviously wasn’t.
A brick kiln was established on the grounds and it was ready to start burning bricks for the main building in June of 1888. Work continued sporadically, as weather and funding permitted. The ballooning budget caused loans and liens to be taken out on the property. People who had pledged subscriptions had to be publicly shamed in the newspapers to pay what they promised.
Throughout the construction process, the college was referred to as the Presbyterian College, Western Kansas College, or College of Western Kansas.
The natives were getting understandably restless. A shortage of bricks further delayed construction. As did a payroll shortage.

The arrangement between Soule and the Presbytery was confusing and confounding and Powelson found himself in the position of explaining the situation to the community.
The College of Western Kansas opened on its new campus September 18, 1888. Since the main building still hadn’t been completed, classes were held in the dormitory building. College President Reverend J. M. Wright arrived right on time. In the absence of a streetcar line, a bus route was established for the students and faculty. Claude McCarty was one of the students attending the college that Fall and he often skipped the bus and rode to class on his bicycle.
Powelson’s son, Charles, drowned in a lake on the irrigation ditch on September 24, 1888. Several workmen at the college tried to save him but they were too late. I read articles published years later that blamed the college’s failure on Powelson’s inability to set his grief aside and run the college. Those articles were disgraceful and completely false.
Construction on the main building was continually delayed by brick shortages and a lack of funding. Many have blamed the dysfunction on the Presbyterians but it really does seem the hold-up was on Soule’s side.

By the first week of December, it was hoped the main building could be fully enclosed by New Year’s Day. Unfortunately, the masons went on strike again and the first of the year again passed. In January of 1889, work was delayed by poor weather.

I should note that the Presbyterians were being held accountable for recruiting faculty and students and operating a college to which they did not yet hold the title. Soule was to retain ownership of the property until the buildings were completed. This was an impossible endeavor for everyone involved.
Despite the challenges, this plucky student body began a campus newsletter.

The college announced the main building would be opening on September 10, 1889. Did it? No! But the roof was on by September 18. So they had that going for them. But then they said November 1. Finally, the main building was “completed” in December of 1889.

It turns out the contract stipulated $20,000 for the endowment could not be released until the college building was completed. That does make one wonder if the delays were intentional. Meanwhile, Asa Soule died on January 17, 1890. This made everything even more complicated. Soule’s son, Wilson, was appointed temporary administrator in February. I would argue the claims against the estate definitely did exceed $2,500 but that’s just me.

The college informally took possession of the new building on March 24 but the deed hadn’t been signed over to the college before Soule died. This meant they then had to negotiate with the heirs. There was also the matter of subcontractors who hadn’t been paid. Obtaining a clear title to the property was impossible.

In May, a meeting was held to try and resolve the outstanding issues.

The college still hadn’t been turned over to the Presbytery by August of 1890. Regardless, operations continued.
In October of 1890, the college Board of Trustees reported “Nothing new had developed in regard to the financial condition, except a difficulty in the settlement of some liens on the Building, involving a further delay in the adjustment of our claims.”
Lacking the promised endowment funds and title to the property, Reverend Wright left the college in November of 1890 and moved to Parsons, Kansas.

Reverend Powelson was right behind him and that was the end of the College of Western Kansas.
The Presbytery attempted to wrap up their financial obligations while they pursued claims against the Soule estate in the courts.

I’ve read many later articles about the first college failing because the Presbyterians couldn’t agree on much of anything related to the financing or management of the college. In reality, the responsibility appeared to lie with the Soule family. I’ll delve into the college’s second act in a future post.
If you like what you see, be sure to subscribe (way at the bottom of the post on mobile devices) to receive an email each time a new post is published and share on social media. You can also buy me a cup of coffee using the donation form. Thanks for reading!
Donation
Your support keeps the content flowing! Make a one-time donation. Your contribution is appreciated!
$5.00












